deltaburnt

2 tháng trướcdiscuss

LLMs aren't nearly mature or deterministic enough to earn that distinction. I've had an agent tell me it read a link I gave it, when actually it lied. I don't see how you could possibly compare that to a compiler where thinking "maybe it's a compiler bug" means you've almost certainly missed something.

deltaburnt

4 tháng trướcdiscuss

I think the kind of surface level rewrites that people rag on are pretty rare, at least in my experience. Realistically code that's impossible to understand, underdocumented, and lacking in proper abstractions is also deficient code. If you've ensured that the code is "good enough", you will likely hit a bug or feature request that is hindered by the poor structure and understanding of the code.

It's totally fine to say "the code works, that area is stable, let's not mess with that code". I make those kinds of tradeoffs on a near daily basis. But let's be real, "perfectly functioning code" is an ill defined, moving target. What looks like perfectly functioning code to a sibling team or a PM, could be a massive liability to someone who actually knows the code.

But then again I'm writing OS and performance critical code. A 1 in 1 million bug is easier to ignore in a throwaway log viewer website.

deltaburnt

5 tháng trướcdiscuss

I don't think we should use webdev as an example of why lossy copy and paste works for the industry.

deltaburnt

6 tháng trướcdiscuss

For pretty much every single person you or I personally know, that would be the equivalent of the end of humanity.

Let’s not nitpick here. Worldwide human suffering and tragedy is equivalent to the end of humanity for most.

We can sit here and armchair while in the most prosperous, comfortable era of human history. But we also have to recognize that this era is a blip of time in history. That is a lot of data showing humanity surviving sure. But it’s also a very small amount of data showing any kind of life most would want to live in.

deltaburnt

7 tháng trướcdiscuss

This is a pretty discriminatory comment that I’ve honestly seen zero hint of in reality. And this is coming from someone who didn't go to a particularly prestigious school. I honestly rarely even find out what school my colleagues went to school. But the ones I know who did go to those prestigious schools are beyond humble.

deltaburnt

7 tháng trướcdiscuss

Much less money lost, but Amazon is notorious for not providing free game codes that are supposed to be included with GPU purchases. The customer rep at first apologized and offered a small refund (less than the cost of the game). A later rep started implying I was trying to defraud Amazon.

Many people online share similar experiences. Wonder how much money this wide-scale fraud saves them.

deltaburnt

8 tháng trướcdiscuss

Basically locks you out of HDR, high frame rates, VRR, or (more importantly) new panel technology like OLED.

deltaburnt

8 tháng trướcdiscuss

I don't really buy your premise. What you're suggesting is that all code has bugs, and those bugs have equal severity and distribution regardless of any forethought or rigor put into the code.

You're right, human review and thorough design are a poor approximation of proving assumptions about your code. Yes bugs still exist. No you won't be able to prove the correctness of your code.

However, I can pretty confidently assume that malloc will work when I call it. I can pretty confidently assume that my thoroughly tested linked list will work when I call it. I can pretty confidently assume that following RAII will avoid most memory leaks.

Not all software needs meticulous careful human review. But I believe that the compounding cost of abstractions being lost and invariants being given up can be massive. I don't see any other way to attempt to maintain those other than human review or proven correctness.

deltaburnt

8 tháng trướcdiscuss

In this context I meant throwaway as "low stakes" not "meaningless". Again, evaluating the output of a database import like that could be existensial for your company given the context. Not to mention there's many cases where evaluating the output isn't feasible for a human.

deltaburnt

8 tháng trướcdiscuss

I don’t think I’ve ever seen someone seriously argue that personal throwaway projects need thorough code reviews of their vibe code. The problem comes in when I’m maintaining a 20 year old code base used by anywhere from 1M to 1B users.

In other words you can’t vibe code in an environment where evaluating “does this code work” is an existential question. This is the case where 7k LOC/day becomes terrifying.

Until we get much better at automatically proving correctness of programs we will need review.

deltaburnt

9 tháng trướcdiscuss

Literally everything will say AI generated to avoid potential liability. You'll have a "known to the state of California to cause cancer" situation.

deltaburnt

9 tháng trướcdiscuss

Thank you for sharing this holy crap. I have this exact monitor and that popup drives me absolutely insane.

deltaburnt

9 tháng trướcdiscuss

It really depends on the engineer. I've seen some engineers in that exact position you describe, their job description says they influence the org broadly so that's what they set out to do. They struggle against a political and technical machine, vying for power, and trying to build a fiefdom.

Other engineers I've seen (a smaller sunset) have that job description more as an observation of their skills and influence. Their mandate isn't to influence, they just do. They are respected for their vast knowledge, historical success, and insight. So they naturally are heeded by most, and consequently they broadly influence the org.

Both cases sound miserable in their own way, but if I had to choose I'd much rather land in the latter. The latter still involves some politics, but at least it sounds like you're not wasting your life playing stupid games.

deltaburnt

9 tháng trướcdiscuss

Aren't you effectively saying that no one will understand the code they're actually deploying? That's always true to an extent, but at least today you mostly understand the code in your sub area. If we're saying the future is AI + careful review, how am I going to have enough context to even do that review?

deltaburnt

10 tháng trướcdiscuss

This isn't really porn adopting ChatGPT, it's OpenAI allowing porn. There was nothing stopping Pornhub from releasing their own LLM. If porn became a feature gated behind YouTube Premium I would probably say "wow they really need customers huh".

deltaburnt

11 tháng trướcdiscuss

I mean, there's very specific reasons either color gets support from their voters. I wouldn't say all of those reasons warrant the same amount of fervor, passion, and loyalty that they do. But "blind support" is a bit reductive when for some people it literally means their rights being stripped away.

What appears to be "blind support" is people desperately clinging onto what tiny bit of representation they have. It's sad for both sides. It's Stockholm syndrome mixed with political pragmatism. It sucks, but the current political landscape in the US has entrenched itself so deeply in a local minima that people feel like they have to work backwards to make progress. Just see how any discussion of a third party is seen as a psyop to get that side to have a spoiler effect.

deltaburnt

11 tháng trướcdiscuss

I think most people aren't leaving their house each day with the same worries people in the 20th century had. It is certainly much nicer to be alive now than then, especially in places like Europe.

What personally has me worried is the derivative and 2nd derivative. How much is my current comfort sustained purely because of the momentum of systems made possible less than a lifetime ago (post WW2 reconstruction). So ironically your comment induces more stress in me. The idea that just as recently as the 20th century, times that my grandparents were conscious for, that many people lived through that much suffering. To me it seems incredibly easy to end up right back there.

deltaburnt

11 tháng trướcdiscuss

Honestly this is one of the undersold advantages of public transit. It can be fun to optimize your path and switch things up both on a macro and micro timescale. In a car since I'm constantly aware of what I'm doing, taking a less efficient path feels like I'm wasting a part of my life. Taking a less efficient path on public transit feels like I'm taking more time to stop and appreciate my surroundings. Especially because sometimes that alternate path gives me a better view.

A coworker once told me his view of his commute drastically changed when he realized he could take the ferry to work. He got fresh air, it was less cramped, and it only took an extra 5-10 minutes.

deltaburnt

11 tháng trướcdiscuss

The restrictions are initially limited to those countries.

deltaburnt

11 tháng trướcdiscuss

When I started, I was told that one of the easier ways to get promo at L5 was to become a manager. I don't know how true that was at the time, but I think this could be a consequence of that sort of local optimizing. I think now they don't even allow you to be a manager at L5 unless you're grandfathered in?

comments