Ask HN: Please review my webapp - AwesomeVocab.com
17 comments
* Its very simple.
* Animation is wasted on me, this is from somebody who at least writes like he has some experience in the field.
http://foolsworkshop.com/reviews/issues the very first issue is "The Flip Fixation Flaw". I have to agree with him, its just not something I want to see. Im here to learn.
* I know its a simple app and all, but would be better if I could make my own.
* I commend you on hiding the interface! I have seen quizlet and many others who overwhelm your screen with more than what you are trying to learn. Im here to learn not be told about the groups latest comment. So once again top work on focusing on whats important.
* Nice to see that the webapp is php and not RoR.
* Contradicting "gursikh" comments, I do think there is a chance to monetise such concepts. But he is right, you do have some competition, but you dont need millions of users. You just need to wow a few thousand. ( I think )
* I know its a simple app and all, but would be better if I could make my own.
* I commend you on hiding the interface! I have seen quizlet and many others who overwhelm your screen with more than what you are trying to learn. Im here to learn not be told about the groups latest comment. So once again top work on focusing on whats important.
* Nice to see that the webapp is php and not RoR.
* Contradicting "gursikh" comments, I do think there is a chance to monetise such concepts. But he is right, you do have some competition, but you dont need millions of users. You just need to wow a few thousand. ( I think )
>* I know its a simple app and all, but would be better if I could make my own.
Make your own word lists?
Make your own word lists?
Yes, make my own word lists. Just like you are thinking of making other packages. Maybe I just want to learn capital cities in Europe. Or something equally random.
I think it's a great, simple application. I think my vocabulary is a bit extensive for it (did a dozen or so, got them all), but it would still be useful.
My comments: a) The animation is distracting, b) I didn't know at first that I was supposed to click a definition (you should add a "click the right one" instruction), c) I wish there were keyboard shortcuts to pick an answer, d) When you mouseover the answers the background changes, yet you can't click the background [1].
As for monetization, you may have a market with students studying for spelling bees or standardized tests or whatever. Some parents would spend ridiculous amounts of money if they think it will help their children.
[1] EDIT: Ignore this one. I don't know why I said that you can't click the background.
My comments: a) The animation is distracting, b) I didn't know at first that I was supposed to click a definition (you should add a "click the right one" instruction), c) I wish there were keyboard shortcuts to pick an answer, d) When you mouseover the answers the background changes, yet you can't click the background [1].
As for monetization, you may have a market with students studying for spelling bees or standardized tests or whatever. Some parents would spend ridiculous amounts of money if they think it will help their children.
[1] EDIT: Ignore this one. I don't know why I said that you can't click the background.
Great ideas! Added "choose the right answer" and removed the distracting animation. Does it look better now?
Thanks, that's perfect.
EDIT: Oh, and I realized what I meant about not being able to click the background: the number next to the answer should be clickable.
EDIT 2: Also, it only shows the "click the correct answer" message the first time. I'm not sure if that was your intention.
EDIT: Oh, and I realized what I meant about not being able to click the background: the number next to the answer should be clickable.
EDIT 2: Also, it only shows the "click the correct answer" message the first time. I'm not sure if that was your intention.
[deleted]
Yep, it is intensional. After the first time, I guess people would know that they have to click on the right answer?
I'm unclear if this does spaced repetition like SuperMemo and Anki. If it does, you should make it clear. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spaced_repetition
Yes, it does use my own (hacked) version of spaced repetition. Mainly there are stages for learning words. Words get repeated often if you get them wrong and they get repeated less often as you get them right.
Here is the clickable link - http://www.awesomevocab.com/
I've found your app addictive and useful (I'm prepping for the GRE), but it's a bit buggy in FF 3 on OSX and on my iphone.
1) animation on the word/choices occasionally flashes repeatedly, usually around 5 times in a row, but sometimes requires a page refresh to get it to stop
2) I've found that after a point some of the words are repeated more than 3 times and if I answer those words correctly for the 4th time I get a point reduced from my "words mastered" count
Otherwise, great clean interface. Well done.
1) animation on the word/choices occasionally flashes repeatedly, usually around 5 times in a row, but sometimes requires a page refresh to get it to stop
2) I've found that after a point some of the words are repeated more than 3 times and if I answer those words correctly for the 4th time I get a point reduced from my "words mastered" count
Otherwise, great clean interface. Well done.
1. Not sure about the animation... when I'm in the mood for studying, I really want to pound through things. The animation should either be really fast or not there at all.
2. Not sure if it fits in this model, but I find example sentences to be very helpful when learning vocab.
can you give it a button to get another word without having to refresh the page (or just make it refresh the page for you)?
You'd be surprised how many people won't know how to get another word.
You'd be surprised how many people won't know how to get another word.
Hmm.. I am not sure I understood your comment completely. What do you mean by refreshing the page? The flow is Word and list of options -> click on one option -> correct answer is displayed -> click on next work -> next word and options is displayed
Where do you need to refresh? Perhaps it is a browser issue?
Where do you need to refresh? Perhaps it is a browser issue?
I get the same result in firefox 3.5.2 / ubuntu jaunty 64 bit.
Word and list of options -> click on one option -> correct answer is displayed -> click on next word -> blank screen
I can refresh the page and get a new word.
Word and list of options -> click on one option -> correct answer is displayed -> click on next word -> blank screen
I can refresh the page and get a new word.
Yup I see the problem. Just trying to fix it.
Oh no, my bad. Was using console.log -- therefore it wasn't working.
Funny, when I had Firebug opened, it worked. Now removed console.log and it should work without refreshing.
Funny, when I had Firebug opened, it worked. Now removed console.log and it should work without refreshing.
In that case, you've to make it a lot more clear that this is a quiz.
Start with adding "a.", "b.", "c." etc. at the start of each answer choice.
Btw, I have an offer for you:) Added you on gtalk.
Start with adding "a.", "b.", "c." etc. at the start of each answer choice.
Btw, I have an offer for you:) Added you on gtalk.
Good suggestion. Updated the app. Check it out now :)
I totally get that you're trying to be super cautious about every letter. But I'd still put something like "choose an answer:"
1) I like the full screen format of the application. It really lends to memorizing words without distraction.
2) I like the way you've implemented multiple choice rather that a "flash card" approach.
that being said, i've seen several apps like this. the most prominent in my memory is http://quizlet.com which has more than one way of memorizing list, classrooms groups, and the ability to create your own lists. and it's free. that's tough to compete with.
2) I like the way you've implemented multiple choice rather that a "flash card" approach.
that being said, i've seen several apps like this. the most prominent in my memory is http://quizlet.com which has more than one way of memorizing list, classrooms groups, and the ability to create your own lists. and it's free. that's tough to compete with.
Thanks.
Yep I understand that there are a lot of similar websites. But it was my attempt to make an app that I would have wished had existed when I was preparing for my GRE exam.
Yep I understand that there are a lot of similar websites. But it was my attempt to make an app that I would have wished had existed when I was preparing for my GRE exam.
Very nice interface. I tried it out and had the following problems:
1) In 17 words, "arboretum" and "impetus" came up twice. 17 words is way too soon to start repeating. 2) The words appear to be of uniform difficulty. They aren't very hard and you don't progress as you go along. It may be better to start off with easy words and progressively get harder as the user keeps going.
Overall, I thought it was a cute idea. All the best.
1) In 17 words, "arboretum" and "impetus" came up twice. 17 words is way too soon to start repeating. 2) The words appear to be of uniform difficulty. They aren't very hard and you don't progress as you go along. It may be better to start off with easy words and progressively get harder as the user keeps going.
Overall, I thought it was a cute idea. All the best.
Thanks.
Yes, the words you answer correct repeat progressively after 15 words, then 150 words and then 500 words (just to be sure it doesn't slip off your memory).
Perhaps I need to way to determine if a word is already known versus if a person has just learnt it.
Yes, the words you answer correct repeat progressively after 15 words, then 150 words and then 500 words (just to be sure it doesn't slip off your memory).
Perhaps I need to way to determine if a word is already known versus if a person has just learnt it.
I like how everything is clean and polished, though the only gripe I have is that the formatting for the results page is a big awkward. Having four different elements in the corners of the screen was distracting and my eyes had to travel a lot to read everything. It would be a good idea to either make everything compact, or on the same side. At least in my opinion.
I really love your app. Simple, effective and very well executed.
Is there any chance of getting a pronunciation button? I had a few words that I knew but wasn't sure on exactly how to say them. I ended up looking them up elsewhere but it would be nice if it was included in your app.
Overall I like the app, and not being a native speaker there's quite a few words it could help me learn even with its current vocab.
Found a minor issue, though: the links in the upper right are clickable, even when they aren't visible.
Found a minor issue, though: the links in the upper right are clickable, even when they aren't visible.
Very well done. If this was a game, I'd like to have the ability to select two answers: if one of them is right I'd get half a point instead of a full point.
Hehe, I'd say it still needs some polish:
misanthrope:
option: .... option: one who hates mankind; misanthropist option: ...
misanthrope:
option: .... option: one who hates mankind; misanthropist option: ...
I think you need a difficulty rating, the words were too easy for me so I got bored, i might play on a harder mode.
please make it more difficult! the words are commonly used.
I found some words which are not commonly used (ken - range of knowledge; Ex. beyond one's ken).
At least they're words not used by anyone I know.. but maybe that says more about who I hang out with than whether they're commonly used..
At least they're words not used by anyone I know.. but maybe that says more about who I hang out with than whether they're commonly used..
Nice work!
To take a break from my serious startup attempt, I decided to spare two days for creating this vocabulary webapp which my was simply dominating my mindshare. This is the link to the webapp - http://www.awesomevocab.com/
Main idea was to remove distractions from learning vocabulary and then providing realtime feedback on the progress. Things that I am considering adding to the webapp: a) adding more vocab packs (SAT, GMAT, languages other than English) b) Monetization? (I'm not sure if people would pay for this app) c) iPhone/Facebook interface
I will appreciate if you can provide feedback on it. Thanks.