On the other hand, I consider v8 the most extreme optimized runtime in a weird way, in that there’re like 100 people on the planet understand how it works, while the rest of us be like “why my JS not fast”
Obviously the article is making valid points. But a recent epiphany I had is, things by default are just mediocre but works. Of course the first shot at this problem is not going to be very good, very much like the first version of JavaScript is a shitshow and we’ll take years to pay down the technical debts. In order to force a beautiful creation, significant effort and will power needs to be put in place. So Id say I’m not surprised at all and this is just how the world works, in most cases.
I agree except I think 100 lines is definitely worth a method, whereas 15 lines is obviously not worthy for the most cases and yet we do that a lot.
My principle has always been: “is this part a isolated and intuitive subroutine that I can clearly name and when other people see it they’ll get it at first glance without pausing to think what this does (not to mention reading through the implemention)”. I’m surprised this has not been a common wisdom from many others.
Engineers at small startups are generally founder minded. They’re like founders, and are passionate about the product and the problem. That’s how they get to decide/involve in the decision about what to work on
Another question is, what motivated you to start this effort in the first place? And why do you think it's useful. I haven't read the book, so not really sure
What you said makes sense, but only to limited set of people.
Not all people are interested/capable of learning how it works underneath. There're like, I don't know, hundreds of thousands of React developers in the world, very few of them understand how React really works underneath.
This is actually one of the goals that React was invented and popularized inside Facebook. It's just sooo easy to pick up and start building.
That being said, for our product, it's not only about React and its basics. We can totally create a workout project for React internals. That depends on what you guys need :) We started with these two projects because it seems a common useful and popular thing, and we're able to do them ourselves.
> That said I don’t often get asked for source code during interviews these days, so probably the ability to host the minified code for a demo would be enough.
I'm a little bit confused about this piece. Are you suggesting we host the minified code on our site + the demo? Because in the first part, I thought you wouldn't want that because employer should see this as a tutorial thing if they see anything on a third party website other than your own website?
Sounds like a good idea to provide a free trial. But I also want to make sure that people are actually interested in paying.
What specifically do you mean, by "how the spec is laid out, and how the solution is laid out"? I guess I understand the spec part, but what about the solution?
The from-university statement, so true, it's an art. We're trying to explore to find the perfect balance :)
That's actually... interesting.
I haven't thought about it this way. I guess you mean people want it to be part their portfolio, which actually makes a lot of sense.
I don't have the best answer yet, but I guess one thing is that, we could host the source code on our site and have some sort of portfolio page here.
I'm curious about why you chose to open source it. For me personally, I would be happy to pay for the hosted version if it's useful, and not worry about hosting my own.
On the job seeking perspective, what you said is right. Typically what people do is signing an NDA, but even with that, the question/solution still sometimes leak on the Internet.
On the learning scenario, it's sorta true, but mostly sharing the solution would ruin the motivation, at least for me personally. If I know there's a solution sitting there, I wouldn't be interested in repeating it again.
I know it's sorta silly... But my mind works best when I only focus on the problem, and how to solve it. As long as I know there's a solution, I couldn't stop myself looking at it whenever I was stuck at any tiny bit.