If we reveal our idea in our YC app and don't accept, would YC possibly recommend it to other, participating teams?
7 comments
That addresses the question partially. It says they're not going to do anything short-sighted and evil like others might.
I think it's wise to trust the YC partners not to do anything intentionally nefarious, but to assume the worst of their unconscious minds.
When smart people read hundreds of ideas its got to cause a huge swarm in their heads. Most of the ideas get immediately buried in the unconscious. There's a definite chance a YC applicant's idea could eventually emerge and find its way in into a YC-funded company, in some form.
I definitely don't think this is a reason to not submit your application though. Everyone is going to know your idea after you launch anyway. If secrecy is your biggest asset you're in so much trouble this is a trivial concern.
I think it's wise to trust the YC partners not to do anything intentionally nefarious, but to assume the worst of their unconscious minds.
When smart people read hundreds of ideas its got to cause a huge swarm in their heads. Most of the ideas get immediately buried in the unconscious. There's a definite chance a YC applicant's idea could eventually emerge and find its way in into a YC-funded company, in some form.
I definitely don't think this is a reason to not submit your application though. Everyone is going to know your idea after you launch anyway. If secrecy is your biggest asset you're in so much trouble this is a trivial concern.
They're going to give your ideas to your closest competitors. Haven't you heard of Competitor Day?
/old
But seriously, ideas are totally worthless. I thought my totally awesome idea for a productivity site was worth a billion dollars too. And I built it and released it, and you know what? Nobody cared, and rightly so, because it was poorly executed. Now I'm playing catch-up with the design by making things cleaner, streamlined, and simple. That is what matters, not whatever your idea is. Though it's not until you've been steamrolled by brett and his clickable calendar that one can really understand that, maybe. :)
/old
But seriously, ideas are totally worthless. I thought my totally awesome idea for a productivity site was worth a billion dollars too. And I built it and released it, and you know what? Nobody cared, and rightly so, because it was poorly executed. Now I'm playing catch-up with the design by making things cleaner, streamlined, and simple. That is what matters, not whatever your idea is. Though it's not until you've been steamrolled by brett and his clickable calendar that one can really understand that, maybe. :)
To play devil's advocate, what if YC folks have already thought of the idea you had(and obviously did not pick you for reasons other than your idea)? See, it goes both ways.
Bottomline: it is very difficult in this environment with start-ups launching left and right to claim ownership of a certain idea, even between two parties.
Bottomline: it is very difficult in this environment with start-ups launching left and right to claim ownership of a certain idea, even between two parties.
I got the impression that the YCs had discussed the idea my team applied with before we had applied. This only helped us land the interview, because they knew we were trying to tackle a big, important unsolved problem.
They certainly haven't launched a company doing what we wanted to do and no other YC company has, so you really don't need to worry about them stealing/sharing your idea. It's just not worth it for them.
They certainly haven't launched a company doing what we wanted to do and no other YC company has, so you really don't need to worry about them stealing/sharing your idea. It's just not worth it for them.
PG has answered this - no.
No.
"We don't make any formal promise about secrecy, but we don't plan to let anyone outside Y Combinator see these applications, including other startups we fund."