White House Proposes Evenly Cutting Water Allotments from Colorado River(nytimes.com)

18 pointsby bgc3년 전4 comments

White House Proposes Evenly Cutting Water Allotments from Colorado River

https://www.nytimes.com/2023/04/11/climate/colorado-river-water-cuts-drought.html

2 comments

This is a good occasion to point to the excellent novel The Water Knife by Paolo Bacigalupi. I think I first heard of it here on HN, and it was described as a "Sci-Fi" novel--sadly, we're approaching the point where we'll have to relabel it as a neo-noir dramatization of current events.

The novel name checks the nonfiction book The Cadillac Desert by Marc Reisner which is also excellent background.

tschwimmer3년 전

I read the Water Knife on an HN recommendation and I can't say I agree. I like Sci Fi in general, so it was an easy sell. Even then it didn't win me over. I'd characterize the writing as amateurish. Lots of problems with uneven pacing (novels grinds on and on in the beginning where nothing much happens and then an insane dash to the denouement) and half baked character development (the main character is classic ruthless thug who grows a heart, but his shift is pretty abrupt and under-developed). I find that serious flaws like that can be carried by good worldbuilding (For example Altered Carbon) but it didn't do very well there either. Some interesting ideas like the arcologies, but all pretty generic post-apocalypse dystopia stuff. The one thing the novel does well is provide a basic explanation of the rules of water rights and water management but that's definitely not enough to redeem it.

I also read Cadillac Desert after reading The Water Knife, and I enjoyed it much more. It's a pretty wide ranging book but does a nice job of weaving together all context it builds up. The one criticism that I have is that it seems pretty alarmist. The author stops just short of predicting impending collapse but the book was written in 1986 and we're just now getting to a crisis level after a historical drought.

matthewmcg3년 전

Thanks--these are good criticisms. I agree with you that the strength of the Water Knife was more in the conceptual parts and the imagined world--often these were just mentioned rather than fully built out, like certain events that are just shown as news footage while a character is waiting in a lobby.

Termination Shock was similar.

I would definitely like to read more speculative fiction on this topic!

cyanydeez3년 전

Better would be to eminent domain it, auction it at rates of appropriate economic value and ban water exports outside the states.

All these half measures are no better than doing nothing.