Improving collaboration with forks(github.com)

https://github.com/blog/2247-improving-collaboration-with-forks

7 comments

This is huge. With Hack Club (https://github.com/hackclub/hackclub) we get a fair amount of PRs from beginners that have one or two minor issues.

We eventually gave up trying to get beginners to fix their pull requests and would manually pull their work to our personal forks, fix it, and then open up new pull requests.

Very excited to see this fixed.

labster10년 전

It was always possible to send PRs into other PRs, because a pull request is just a branch attached to an issue tracker. I've done it before, but not with newbies. This looks like a nice improvement to the interface, though.

zachlatta10년 전

Yeah, we started by trying that. To be frank, it turned into a clusterfuck pretty quickly because most beginners that send PRs our way don't understand their internals (i.e. that PRs are linked to branches).

petetnt10년 전

This is great. Occasionally I jump into helping with some PRs (for example https://github.com/adobe/brackets/pull/12251) and before the choices have been either making the changes and asking for the contributor to pull the changes in from some other branch, posting some `.diff`s or just pulling the changes in and pushing them in yourself. This will make all that much simple and best of all more collaborative.

jMyles10년 전

I have been envisioning such a feature for a while. I can imagine some pitfalls, but I think that my teams will be working this into our approach pretty quickly.

lux10년 전

For small tweaks, this is great. I have been wanting this for years. Oh yessss

OJFord10년 전

Yes! Saves the PRs on PRs...