I did use an LLM to workshop my comms; I tend to go on and on so I put my my comments through a LLM to clean up my replies. the opinions and the project are mine, but the polish isn't. I'll knock it off for the rest of this thread.
True and decent read. Holos is a generic runner underneath, and I'm not trying to compete on the curated-OS-image front; the assumption is you bring a cloud image and cloud-init does the rest.
Unattended installs for Linux work today through cloud-init (that's most of what the YAML drives). Windows/macOS would need a different path.. autounattend.xml injection for Windows, custom payload for macOS; I haven't built that. If there's interest, a provisioner: type block that picks the right unattend mechanism based on OS isn't crazy, but it's not on the near-term list.
Docker does have both docker run and docker compose... Holos is compose-only right now. A holos run on top of the same VM machinery isn't a huge lift; mostly it's deciding what the sensible defaults are (image, cloud-init user, port, volume scope); Noted. it's not in 0.1 but I hear the ask.
Your path makes a ton of sense too! You get typed languages, state management, and the Incus team's work on the QEMU layer. The tradeoff I wasn't willing to make is the daemon + state store: Incus wants to own the VM lifecycle the way libvirtd does, and once you have that you're back to "two sources of truth" if you ever shell out. Holos is deliberately stateless on the host; Everything lives under one directory per project, rm -rf is a valid uninstall (though it will abandon the VMs if running). Different answer to the same frustration. Would genuinely like to see your thing when it's public.
Thanks! Honest answer: nope. Holos talks to QEMU directly and skips libvirt entirely — that's deliberate (no XML, no daemon, state lives in a single directory per project), but I like the idea of being able to import vm's. I will try to find some time to add that feature.
Fair — the YAML shape is similar. The differences that matter to me: GPU passthrough works without fighting the provider plugin ecosystem, healthchecks gate depends_on instead of you sleeping in a provisioner, and there's no Ruby, no vagrant reload, no box format.
This article is so one sided it is painful. it is almost like Sheldon Cooper wrote this article. As an engineer I am offended and hurt that we are referred to as “Tony Stark’s tailor”.
Why is it cheaper to live in China then the USA? Because China has a huge import/export deficit and artificial devaluation of currency. It does not play part to the global economy like others do through deliberate manipulation. It remains true that this is simple exploitation on a national scale.
no they are being pinched by the artificial devaluation of a currency in comparison to other currencies set by a foreign government. If all other things were held true and this was global market, this wouldn't work. My argument holds true historically as nations 'grow up'. This is exploitation, pure and simple.
I haven't been to China specifically, but I have been to Germany, Japan, Mexico, Canada, all over the USA, Poland, and France. I HAVE spoke with painters, not normally by choice lol (because my wife is one) and universally the pinch is felt. Reproduction work is the bread and butter of most fine artists to pay for their living and fund their original work.
Oh and the PAINT alone in the USA ranges from the crazy gonna like posion you cheap (~5 bucks/color US dollars) to expensive (80 bucks/color US dollars). That doesn't even cover canvas, brushes, or space to paint in. lets not forget about time. A persons' time is worth something too. Explain to me how an artist can survive with material costs like that on 50-400 a painting when it takes hours/days for one person to paint a reproduction.
[edit]
I forgot about gesso, that isn't cheap either.
And now I know why so many fine artists can't find work unless it is purely original work (a highly volatile market). I am saddened deeply that even art has degraded to this. if you want a print, buy a print from a printing machine. You want an oil painting? Hire or barter with a local artist to do so. I can't even. I just can't even.
Food carts are a perfect example of COGS in action. Coffee places are also an example (SBUX, stumptown, etc). Highly specialized businesses selling items at the best balance of COGS and quality.
Food carts and small specialized brick and mortar businnesses are succeeding because their COGS are far lower then your average place.
Most resturants fail because of their initial COGS at startup and because their food/service/merketing research generally sucks for where they are. Remove the service aspect, specialize, reduce cogs, make a living wage.
I cooked for a little over a decade all said and told. Eight of those ten years I made less then $10 bucks/hour. Food is a difficult thing to make money on in the USA. Without margin, wages cannot increase. Last time I checked margin in the food business was less then 3% of total revenue. let me say that again, 3%. It MAY be worse now. Mass production is the ONLY way to stay afloat for a food business. Thus employees that are not a part of the service portion of the business, feel the squeeze.
To fix the problem, look no further then COGS.
1. Smaller menus (less margin in the trash)
2. Aggressively seasonal selections (cheaper then any other food)
3. Be a part of the community you are serving (intangible but sticky customer base)
4. Pair down customer capacity (smaller team = more hours per employee)
5. Salaries instead of hourly (cheaper, longer term employees)
6. Add the frickin 5% to that $30 plate of food
7. Consider limited hours (staying open 16 hours is stupid and wasteful)
It's like attacking a tin shed with a chainsaw... from within the shed.