It probably would have been a lot fairer had he compared the iPhone 3GS or iPhone 4 to everything pre-ICS (AKA any android phone on the market). In which case, any iOS device would still win.
We'll have to see how ICS on (Android device) holds up against iOS 5 on 4S.
We'll have to see how ICS on (Android device) holds up against iOS 5 on 4S.