From reading all this I can only reach this conclusion: you guys should try Logaholic Web Analytics. It's waaaay simpler than Google and yields even more detailed results with less digging. You don't need to tag yoyr URLS, because Logaholic (also) works with logfiles, so all your KPI URLs will be automatically uploaded when you install the software on your server. The funnel reports and A/B split testing are way easier to do with Logaholic and you don't need to create a new profile for every single type of data that you want to run reports on. Also, with Logaholic you can upload old log files, so tracking back in the past is also possible! The free trial is here: http://www.logaholic.com/wp/trial-download/.