Ask HN: female being perceived as less convincing on tech subjects?
2 comments
Why not both, and have a link to both?
If you don't think you could pull that off without it being awkward, I feel like I'm not the best person to offer an opinion, since I'm probably not in your target audience. But if I was the person in charge of the decision I'd choose female. This isn't a knock against females, but there's something about a female talking deeply about something incredibly technical that I think a lot of guys will find really sexy and compelling.
However, I really think that the most serious metric you should be considering is charisma in general. Can this person project that they really care about what they're saying? You're gonna get better response to an excited-sounding male than a terrible female actor, and vice-versa.
If you don't think you could pull that off without it being awkward, I feel like I'm not the best person to offer an opinion, since I'm probably not in your target audience. But if I was the person in charge of the decision I'd choose female. This isn't a knock against females, but there's something about a female talking deeply about something incredibly technical that I think a lot of guys will find really sexy and compelling.
However, I really think that the most serious metric you should be considering is charisma in general. Can this person project that they really care about what they're saying? You're gonna get better response to an excited-sounding male than a terrible female actor, and vice-versa.
right to the point. I generally find female who can talk deeply into the topic sexy. but yet finding a passionate voice isn't all that easy.
Personal opinion: I am a big them tech and car enthusiast, a big fan of top gear and such. That being said, there is a certain amount male "comfort" imparted when the presenter is male. I am not saying that I have anything against female presenters/voice, but I would just prefer it to be a guy.
Cars in particular (believe it or not), has been and to the most part a male dominated interest group. Again, personal preference, not generalizing.
Cars in particular (believe it or not), has been and to the most part a male dominated interest group. Again, personal preference, not generalizing.
What I really want to ask is: To people who know lots about car and tech savvy, when a new idea is being talked about, do you prefer a guy or a girl talking about it?
To put it in context: we are making a short video for target audience who are mostly car guys. We wonder which narrative voice we should go for.