Ask HN: What information would you like to see on product labels?
10 comments
I’m from Australia, I really like how we always show the 100g/100ml breakdown of ingredients, not just “serving size”.
This lets you easily compare across products with different sizes.
See https://www.wholekids.com.au/wp-content/uploads/australian-f...
This lets you easily compare across products with different sizes.
See https://www.wholekids.com.au/wp-content/uploads/australian-f...
This is brilliant! I even love the additional information added such as 'you don't have to avoid sugar completely' (are these coloured boxes also visible on the label or is it just for illustrative purposes?).
Normally not, but here’s a more real example, https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcRSEa2t...
Thank you for this. The idea of having some additional explanatory notes alongside each serving as in the first layout you shared is very interesting, almost reminds be of ELI5.
CO2 footprint would be nice, but CO2 isn't only environmental factor to consider. I'd rather have colour-coded stickers with two scales - absolute and relative within a product category.
A sticker on a diesel car would be RED/RED and a sticker on a tiny EV car would be RED/GREEN.
A sticker on an apple from a domestic market would be GREEN/GREEN and an apple imported from a country 1000s miles away would be GREEN/ORANGE.
Ideally, the labeling would be a reflection of a fiscal mechanism to charge for externalities in the entire chain - from production to a sale and disposal.
A sticker on a diesel car would be RED/RED and a sticker on a tiny EV car would be RED/GREEN.
A sticker on an apple from a domestic market would be GREEN/GREEN and an apple imported from a country 1000s miles away would be GREEN/ORANGE.
Ideally, the labeling would be a reflection of a fiscal mechanism to charge for externalities in the entire chain - from production to a sale and disposal.
So it would definitely need to be category specific but I do think this could be a hugely interesting idea for organic products etc
I'd love a dual, absolute/category, scale to make my decisioning easier. If something is green on an absolute scale then it's a smaller problem if I pick a product labeled red on on category scale. But I do know that I shouldn't do that.
Dual scale would make it possible to differentiate between two similar products - an "eco" cotton bag could be orange/green while a single plastic use bag could green/red. This way every one would know that an eco bag is worse than a plastic one unless you use it a lot.
Finally, producers would be motivated to optimise environmental impact of all kinds of products because having a red label would be shameful.
Dual scale would make it possible to differentiate between two similar products - an "eco" cotton bag could be orange/green while a single plastic use bag could green/red. This way every one would know that an eco bag is worse than a plastic one unless you use it a lot.
Finally, producers would be motivated to optimise environmental impact of all kinds of products because having a red label would be shameful.
The traffic light system is used in the UK to show how much sugar/salt/fat is in the product. To be honest it shocked me to see so much red for salt so it definitely was eye opening.
The issue with this, that I can now see, is that it would take government action to make this a requirement. But I can see that there would definitely be a benefit for education the customer.
The issue with this, that I can now see, is that it would take government action to make this a requirement. But I can see that there would definitely be a benefit for education the customer.
Actual calories
Added sugar
Minimum font of 50 or whatever
When you say actual calories, what do you mean?
Sugar etc is all there to view and basically legally required.
Are there any other pieces of information that you would like to see?
Sugar etc is all there to view and basically legally required.
Are there any other pieces of information that you would like to see?
What information would you like to see on a product label?
In my mind I have: ingredient information, producer information (farm details for example), CO2 production output, how recyclable are the materials based on a color scale.