Show HN: Nuuton UI demo. Give me your feedback.(nuuton.com)
nuuton.com
Show HN: Nuuton UI demo. Give me your feedback.
http://nuuton.com
18 comments
A: The "..:" & ":.." everywhere are kinda distracting to me. If they hold any significance, it is lost on me.[1]
B: Are "Hacker News", "/r/programming" etc search results? Trending topics that will be replaced when a search is made? It is hard to tell since it is not functioning.
C: The search placeholder is also confusing. " ..: Nuuton :... /category !description" Again, does "..: :.." have any significance or is this like having "google" as the placeholder in their search field? Is "/category" intended to tell the user they can narrow a search to a certain sub-reddit?
D: Are you trying to brand your product through the search field placeholder? Put your brand/ logo somewhere in the green area instead. You loose all branding when a query is entered into the search field.[2]
Hope I'm not coming across as mean, I think the items I listed above will be some stumbling blocks to new users interacting with your site.
[1]- http://awesomescreenshot.com/0c819pej40
[2]- http://awesomescreenshot.com/06719pgie5
B: Are "Hacker News", "/r/programming" etc search results? Trending topics that will be replaced when a search is made? It is hard to tell since it is not functioning.
C: The search placeholder is also confusing. " ..: Nuuton :... /category !description" Again, does "..: :.." have any significance or is this like having "google" as the placeholder in their search field? Is "/category" intended to tell the user they can narrow a search to a certain sub-reddit?
D: Are you trying to brand your product through the search field placeholder? Put your brand/ logo somewhere in the green area instead. You loose all branding when a query is entered into the search field.[2]
Hope I'm not coming across as mean, I think the items I listed above will be some stumbling blocks to new users interacting with your site.
[1]- http://awesomescreenshot.com/0c819pej40
[2]- http://awesomescreenshot.com/06719pgie5
A <center> tag? I believe it has been deprecated for ages.
Also, you can replace <div class="title/description"> with a description list (https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/HTML/Element/dl).
Also, honestly, it looks rather amateur -- which is okay, it being a work in progress.
Also, honestly, it looks rather amateur -- which is okay, it being a work in progress.
Oh yes, it is hacky. This is me putting the look of the UI, not the actual markup. The markup will be template based and html5 complaint.
In the current iteration, I'd say this isn't a usable UI. As a first time visitor, I'd have no idea what I'm supposed to do or what anything on the page means. The form field is somewhat of a mess because of the placeholders and you need to change the ..: Search :.. button. Make it a prominent and obvious call to action button. Also, make sure the form field itself is responsive like the rest of the page so it doesn't get cut off when I resize the browser.
I have no idea what any of the things below the form field are so I can't comment on that.
As for positives... I like the ASCII picture of Isaac Newton in the source.
This needs a lot of work, but everything starts somewhere.
I have no idea what any of the things below the form field are so I can't comment on that.
As for positives... I like the ASCII picture of Isaac Newton in the source.
This needs a lot of work, but everything starts somewhere.
Considering this as a search engine interface, these are my observations:
- too much whitespace around the search input. I can only see three results
- the input placeholder is confusing. is that the accepted syntax? why is "nuuton" in it?
- results text is too large
- it lacks context. what was matched? is this up-to-date content? what is the domain/URL? where do I click?
- large pink footer. why? shrink it and leave it for legalese
- the ..: :.. thing brings me memories of Geocities
- too much whitespace around the search input. I can only see three results
- the input placeholder is confusing. is that the accepted syntax? why is "nuuton" in it?
- results text is too large
- it lacks context. what was matched? is this up-to-date content? what is the domain/URL? where do I click?
- large pink footer. why? shrink it and leave it for legalese
- the ..: :.. thing brings me memories of Geocities
- too much whitespace around the search input. I can only see three results
The launch version will have up to 50 results.
- the input placeholder is confusing. is that the accepted syntax? why is "nuuton" in it?
No good reason. The / and ! are tools that you will be able to use to search.
- it lacks context. what was matched? is this up-to-date content? what is the domain/URL? where do I click?
Did not put that in here on purpose, due to this being an UI exercise. I do agree its confusing.
- large pink footer. why? shrink it and leave it for legalese
My daughter's input. (:
- the ..: :.. thing brings me memories of Geocities
Those are placeholders.
The launch version will have up to 50 results.
- the input placeholder is confusing. is that the accepted syntax? why is "nuuton" in it?
No good reason. The / and ! are tools that you will be able to use to search.
- it lacks context. what was matched? is this up-to-date content? what is the domain/URL? where do I click?
Did not put that in here on purpose, due to this being an UI exercise. I do agree its confusing.
- large pink footer. why? shrink it and leave it for legalese
My daughter's input. (:
- the ..: :.. thing brings me memories of Geocities
Those are placeholders.
Without something that at least fakes what a typical interaction would be, I don't think anyone could give you feedback aside from whether they like the color/visual treatment.
Not especially keen on the color scheme, I guess. I don't have much of an opinion on the rest of the layout, unfortunately. I'm not sure if that's a good or bad thing.
I appreciate the feedback.
This is the BETA UI. Still tweaking it, though its very close to what you will see on the BETA launch. Let me know what you think. I specially want feedback on how moving around the page feels. There are some features not included in this UI (secret until launch) that will be present later on. And no, Nuuton is not dead. Its more alive than ever.
> I specially want feedback on how moving around the page feels.
So you're saying it's possible to move around the page?
> And no, Nuuton is not dead. Its more alive than ever.
What is Nuuton? (strike that, answered above)
So you're saying it's possible to move around the page?
> And no, Nuuton is not dead. Its more alive than ever.
What is Nuuton? (strike that, answered above)
Feedback for how things are placed in the page. The search ability is not available for the test. Soon, though.
So maybe the importance of Nuuton is lost on me, but I'm going to be honest with you: That is not something I'd feel even remotely confident posting to HN for comments. You are wasting peoples time when you should still be wasting/using a lot more of your own. That this hit the frontpage is baffling.
Where else am I going to get feedback from smart people like you?
It's a give and take. You're taking feedback. For that, it would be wise to give a little more effort.
Not sure why you would have the search button not a button. With forms like this I would either have the button or nothing and expect users to hit the enter key.
The colours a fine in my opinion (although I am not a designer) but the amount of negative space around elements is too much.
The placeholder text in the input box is a bit weird. I would remove the reference to nuuton.