Student charged after alerting principal to server hack(theregister.co.uk)
theregister.co.uk
Student charged after alerting principal to server hack
http://www.theregister.co.uk/2008/10/28/student_charged/
13 comments
I wish I could find the link to where I saw the comment, but I'm having tough time. But anyway, I saw a comment by someone who (mostly politely) emailed the school and chastised them for being so harsh on the student. However, they replied that the student actually had a history of being disobedient, and attempting to break the system. It was also noted that the method he used to alert his administrator was NOT in good faith but more of a 'Ha ha... I broke the system what now?' instead of here's how to fix this. That said, I don't think it's right, but it sounds like he really didn't help his case. As much as it stinks, I think we just have to hope that the people with ALL of the facts will form an appropriate conclusion about the case and justice will be served properly, and not as a means to discourage future attempts to 'fix' security holes.
He may well be a punk, but that doesn't seem like sufficient justification for THREE FELONY CHARGES at age 15.
Dude, he was trying to get a peak at everyone's report cards.
Report Cards!
Report Cards!
I don't think its right that he is being brought with three felony charges AND suspended from school. I could see some sort of school related reprimand...but really...fifteen years old and he shows them up and their best response is lets press federal charges.
Now, assuming that it is true that he has had disobediance problems previously, attempted to break security previously, and was not acting in the form of a white-hat, something should definitely be done. However, that's like saying you're pressing charges against someone for logging into your computer when your password is on a sticky note at the edge of your screen. Not just schools but everyone has to do their own part in order to protect information and the school didn't do their part. I don't have the facts but it would appear that the student did no extraneous work in accessing the information.
I have to say that I, in a way, relate to this situation. When I went to High School I was pretty much watched like a hawk due to my well known understanding and skill on the computer. I was attempted to be blamed numerous times for when something would happen, mostly by a specific administrator who had a grudge against me. Luckily, nothing to this extreme ever happened and its not like I did anything wrong anyways. I ended up working for the school as an Assistant IT Coord my last couple of years.
I'd also like to bring comment to a point made by another comment on here. As far as poor technology policies and idiotic administration, that's one of the things my venture is trying to work on. Understanding that most of the reason these very restrictive policies are there is because of a lack of understanding compounded with a lack of control for what they don't understand. The other major source is fear of reprocussions and dangers. My venture is focused in the area of Educational Technology and part of what we're doing, especially in southern Illinois at the moment, is trying to create tools/programs/systems and structure policies with schools that alleviate the problems both on the administrative side and the student side. Policy work and simplistic administrator friendly systems are something that are a necessity to persuade uptight school districts into not only accepting technology but being more open with students use of it.
...I may have ended up a little off-topic. :P
Now, assuming that it is true that he has had disobediance problems previously, attempted to break security previously, and was not acting in the form of a white-hat, something should definitely be done. However, that's like saying you're pressing charges against someone for logging into your computer when your password is on a sticky note at the edge of your screen. Not just schools but everyone has to do their own part in order to protect information and the school didn't do their part. I don't have the facts but it would appear that the student did no extraneous work in accessing the information.
I have to say that I, in a way, relate to this situation. When I went to High School I was pretty much watched like a hawk due to my well known understanding and skill on the computer. I was attempted to be blamed numerous times for when something would happen, mostly by a specific administrator who had a grudge against me. Luckily, nothing to this extreme ever happened and its not like I did anything wrong anyways. I ended up working for the school as an Assistant IT Coord my last couple of years.
I'd also like to bring comment to a point made by another comment on here. As far as poor technology policies and idiotic administration, that's one of the things my venture is trying to work on. Understanding that most of the reason these very restrictive policies are there is because of a lack of understanding compounded with a lack of control for what they don't understand. The other major source is fear of reprocussions and dangers. My venture is focused in the area of Educational Technology and part of what we're doing, especially in southern Illinois at the moment, is trying to create tools/programs/systems and structure policies with schools that alleviate the problems both on the administrative side and the student side. Policy work and simplistic administrator friendly systems are something that are a necessity to persuade uptight school districts into not only accepting technology but being more open with students use of it.
...I may have ended up a little off-topic. :P
School officials are highly political creatures, and can be very dangerous when cornered. As a 15 yo, even (or especially) the intelligent hacker type, its tempting to think you can handle them or predict their reactions.
You can't.
Its best just to keep your head down, and your yap shut until you've got a little more experience with this kind of person and a little more ability to defend yourself. Hang tight, wait for your release date (I think they call it "graduation") and don't antagonize the guards.
You can't.
Its best just to keep your head down, and your yap shut until you've got a little more experience with this kind of person and a little more ability to defend yourself. Hang tight, wait for your release date (I think they call it "graduation") and don't antagonize the guards.
School administrators are assholes. Policies and actions like this are pretty common place at public high schools. I can't blame them though, they've had to shepherd children around their entire lives, and get paid less than many entry level workers at for profit companies.
While I don't really agree with the "he did nothing wrong" tone of the article, I'm sure this is making a great lesson for the kid: never report technical problems or you'll be charged.
</srcm>
</srcm>
Curious: did the school, in addition to bringing charges against the student, fire the IT person in charge?