Language detection with Google's Compact Language Detector(blog.mikemccandless.com)

75 pointsby davidwvor 15 Jahren12 comments

blog.mikemccandless.com

Language detection with Google's Compact Language Detector

http://blog.mikemccandless.com/2011/10/language-detection-with-googles-compact.html

6 comments

Nice. I've been using a call to the Google online translator to achieve the same result - http://ajax.googleapis.com/ajax/services/language/translate?...

toisanjivor 15 Jahren

are there published api limits on this service?

dangoldinvor 15 Jahren

I'm not aware of them. I'm using this in a high volume/non critical capacity and it seems to be okay. I should keep better stats though.

tha-dudevor 15 Jahren

Nice! I wrote a .NET wrapper myself, never got around to a Python extension though. One question - did you experience any memory leak issues with the CLD? Said, .NET wrapper DLL seems to leak and I never really checked if it was the C++/CLI I added on top or the actual CLD native C++ code. I doubt the latter since (according to my basic understanding) nothing is created in the original code which needs to be cleaned up manually. Before I start debugging mixed-mode .NET applications I just wanted to be sure.

lstrojnyvor 15 Jahren

Great library! Here are bindings for PHP: https://github.com/lstrojny/php-ccld

sick-boyvor 15 Jahren

"You must provide it clean (interchange-valid) UTF-8, so any encoding issues must be sorted out before-hand."

In most cases you have to know the language in order to guess the encoding and convert to UTF-8 if necessary. Mutual recursion...

adambyrtekvor 15 Jahren

Encoding, but obviously not language, should be provided explicitly as metadata (e.g. Content-Type HTTP header). Also, most of content available on the web is already UTF-8 (65.9% according to a recent survey[1]).

[1] http://w3techs.com/technologies/details/en-utf8/all/all

ninjinvor 15 Jahren

Mark Pilgrim reversed (or ripped out, can't remember) the encoding detection that Firefox uses. It has done a fairly good job for my web crawling:

http://pypi.python.org/pypi/chardet

e98cuencvor 15 Jahren

In my experience chardet misclassifies very often iso-8859-1 as iso-8859-2. I saw the misclassification even in small spanish pages, which were using only the typical spanish characters.

Maakuthvor 15 Jahren

I'd say in most cases UTF-8 is already used. Of course this depends on the source of the text.

[deleted]vor 15 Jahren

johnx123-upvor 15 Jahren

I thought that the detection is easier with Unicode ordinal value map table

abhagavor 15 Jahren

I am assuming it will recognize languages even when they are using the same character sets. No?