Ask YC: Is this a good idea?

6 pointsby amarcusvor 18 Jahren7 comments

I've had this idea for about 2-3 years.

In a single sentence: It's google adwords for the real world.

Let me explain: Two types of users: Realestate Owners (RO) and Publishers. An RO will login to a website and enter details about their physical location (where they live etc...). Based on traffic patters calculated automatically, they get assigned a score. This determines how much traffic (cars and pedestrians) go past that location everyday.

A publisher would then login to the website and search for locations they would like to advertise. They choose a location by any number of factors (score, street name etc..) and can put in a bid to advertise at that location.

The RO can then login and accept the bid. After the bid is accepted, the publisher would then send over a mini-billboard that the RO would place in his front yard for everyone to see.

This would not only just work for houses but will also work for cars - if a person travels long distance everyday, then they can get some money back by putting a stickers advertising a product.

I have done minor research on this and it looks feasable.

The way we make money is by takings a percentage of the agreed price between the RO and the publisher.

What does the HN community think?

4 comments

tlrobinsonvor 18 Jahren

I think it's an interesting idea, possibly even feasible as a business.

But if you do it and it becomes widespread I'll hate you for it. I don't want my neighborhood cluttered with more ads than there already are.

amarcusvor 18 Jahren

Thats a good point. I guess we could offer a feature where people say they dont want to receive any ads in a specific location and if enough requests arrive, then that location would be placed on a ban-list.

rmsvor 18 Jahren

Great idea, this could work. I wonder if some areas have laws on the books that prohibit commercial sign sales in residential neighborhoods? I suspect there are some road blocks in the law to prevent blatant commercial signage everywhere.

ScottWhighamvor 18 Jahren

Most mid-price and up neighborhoods do have some types of statues in their bylaws for this and I've often signs are posted at the neighborhood entrance ("No soliciting" or "No handbills").

aneeshvor 18 Jahren

You'd need some way to vet users, so that you could seem credible when selling ads to advertisers. As an advertiser, it'd be hard to me to verify that you're actually displaying my ad, and even harder for me to estimate my ROI.

amarcusvor 18 Jahren

you would need to hire people to go around taking photos of the ads as proof for the advertisers. You could measure roi by simply asking your customers how they heard about you

Tichyvor 18 Jahren

I could imagine that many people would be interested in this.

Also somewhat related, yesterday I read a news item about a monitor that recognizes age and gender of people standing before it and shows suitable ads.